Ethics and the Covid-19 vaccines

 


Amidst the suffering and fear caused by the Covid-19 epidemic,  we have been reading some good news about vaccines being developed and approved that seem to be highly effective in combating the virus.  They have been approved for emergency use in some countries already and may be approved very soon in the U.S.  It looks quite possible that they will be available to some of the public before Christmas. 

There are still many ethical questions that arise about the vaccines (can the government require citizens to take them? Who should get access to them first?  What about privacy? and so on).  But perhaps the most important ethical question is, Is it morally permissible for Catholics to receive them? The question arises because historically some vaccines have been produced from cell lines derived from children killed by abortion, and there is a serious question about whether, by taking such a vaccine, one would be cooperating with a grave moral evil.

There is a very solid group of Catholic priests, doctors and ethicists called the National Catholic Bioethics Center (NCBC).  Our U.S. Bishops have asked them to research the question and the good news is that they have concluded that some of the first released vaccines are morally permissible to use.  I believe this includes the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, but not AstraZeneca.  

I will try to update this post as more information becomes available.  In the meantime, don't hesitate to contact me if you have questions.  

You can read a little more detail on NCBC's ethical analysis here. 

Also, Archbishop Schnurr has asked us pastors to distribute information from his brief letter to pastors on this topic to the faithful.  

Another very helpful resource is the Catholic scientists at the Charlotte Lozier Institute.  If you go to their website and type "vaccine" in the search box at the upper right, you'll find great information.



Popular posts from this blog

Facing the Father together

Image
  For this Advent season only this year (Masses of November 28th through December 23rd), Fr. Reutter will be offering all of his parish Masses in the traditional posture of the Church, with the priest and people together symbolically facing the Father.  (This liturgical orientation is sometimes called by its Latin names, ad orientem or ad Deum  which mean "facing the East" or "facing God [the Father]" This way of celebrating the Mass has centuries-long and ancient roots.  In fact, it was mandatory for much of the Church's history.  After the Second Vatican Council, two options were introduced: the traditional posture or Mass facing the people ( versus populum , to use the Latin phrase).  This resource page has some information on the symbolism behind this option and how it helps to reveal what is happening in the mystery of the Mass. * Fr. Mike Schmitz video, " Pray the Mass like never before ."  This is a general video on the mystery of the Mass, with
Read more

New priests' ordination video

Image
The Archdiocese has recently published a very good 3-minute video of the ordination of three new priests for service to the Archdiocese. You will hear snippets from Archbishop's Schnurr homily and see a few scenes from that ordination Mass.  There are many powerful symbols in that ordination ceremony, including the men about to be ordained priests lying prostrate (on the ground, face down) before the altar, symbolizing that they are dying to themselves as they become "another Christ." In the photo above, after the bishop consecrates the men with prayer and laying on of hands, all of the other priests concelebrating the Mass also lay hands on them, showing that they now share in the one priesthood of Jesus Christ, the great High Priest. You may recognize Fr. Christopher Komoroski.  He was at our South Clermont parishes several weeks when he was still a deacon, to practice his preaching. I had the privilege of "vesting" Fr. Andrew Reckers (helping him put on his
Read more